Showing posts with label erptools. Show all posts
Showing posts with label erptools. Show all posts

Sunday, September 20, 2015

Why is SAP better than other ERP solutions?

Why is SAP better than other ERP solutions?


It is not necessarily better. 

All ERP packages have their strengths and weaknesses. SAP's weakness is that it is very expensive and takes a long time to implement. SAP's strength lies in the ability to develop and customize  - to handle complex business processes that other software doesn't 'fit'- and you can find a thousand Oracle proponents who will claim they can handle the same complex requirement - and they're right. 

The market penetration revolves around client size. If you have 5 customer service reps processing returns, well, Sage ERP has a half a dozen packages that will handle that. However, if you have 500 customer service reps you can use SAP and shave 60 seconds off the time it takes to complete the task with Sage, that's 500 x 60 seconds x 25 transactions per day x 5 days a week x 52 weeks a year x $15 per hour, it's close to a million a year in labor savings. And that's just in customer service. Factor in similar efficiencies in warehousing, delivery, web services, finance, and so on, and suddenly the $5m to install SAP makes sense - even the $3m to upgrade gets approved.  But none of it makes sense until you are in a company large enough to have, say 500 customer service reps worldwide.

SAP is most powerful but it is very expensive as compare to ERP as well it take more time to implement because of its vast modules but once it is implemented then it take of the work of the big organization because small company can't afford SAP package of ERP solutions However it is best enough in its reliability and effective.

ERP in the current Business Requirement !!

Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) is a process oriented methodology which integrates systems used across different departments of a company, enabling easy and uniform flow of information under defined controls, aided by use of software applications and defined best practices.


Any ERP system basically needs to fulfill the following functional requirements.

  1. It must be a unified system, with easy-to-use applications and interfaces, that works seamlessly across multiple departments with the necessary controlled access
  2. A common database (or multiple but shared databases) accessible through different applications
  3. Search and reporting utilities to generate reports based on various parameters
  4. Scalability, customization and easy integration of ad hoc modules, as needed

TOOLS FULFILLING ERP REQUIREMENTS:

To meet the needs of the above mentioned functional requirements, the following tools and applications are mandatorily integrated into the ERP system.

Database Management / Data Warehouse / Information Management Tools:

Data storage and information management with established workflow across different departments and functions are the backbone of any ERP system. Multiple solutions and tools are available for data storage, which include relational databases from companies like Oracle, Sybase, DB2 and open source free offerings like Microsoft MySQL, PostgreSQL, Apache Derby, etc. Other information management tools may include Content Management Systems (CMS) and repository applications.

Depending upon the industry and required functions, an appropriate one needs to be selected. A manufacturer may find a transactional database like Oracle or MySQL to be more relevant as transaction-based data moves through different statuses (from manufacturing to inventory to order capture to sale to supply status). On the other hand, an online content writing company may find a CMS repository system with version control a better fit for their needs.

The database or repository can be either a single centralized one, or multiple with automatic data flow from one database to the other. The defined workflow ensures seamless data movement. Databases can be hosted locally or remotely, or even in the cloud.

Applications and interfaces with suitable permission control:

Data storage and management requires read-only or editing access to process the data. Once items are manufactured, they need to be marked as ready inventory. The stock management department then updates it as ready for sale. Following a purchase, the item should be updated to sold status and so on. To accomplish this, easy to use applications and interfaces make an integral part of any ERP system which also has defined controls and permissions. For e.g., once an item is marked as sold, only logistics department operators should be able to update it further, while the ones from manufacturing or inventory department should get a view only access.

Similarly, for a content writing ERP tool, once a writer submits the content to the editor for review, only the editor should be able to modify it, to avoid any duplication and content conflicts.To enable such permission based controls, applications and interfaces to be built in, any ERP solution which may be browser based, desktop installations or tablet/mobile apps. A manufacturing team at a stationary location will prefer a desktop based interface, while a sales team constantly on the move will benefit from a browser based interface or mobile app.

Workflow Management Tool:

An ERP system constitutes of multiple modules and data repositories where data updates and actions follow a logically defined sequence based on the business needs. This constitutes the workflow. Workflow can be thought of as the mind controlling the various body functions (flow of blood, air, food and other supplies, body parts movement, etc.). A clearly defined workflow with appropriate access at various levels is the necessary part of any ERP solution.Commonly used tools implemented within ERP framework include Agiloft Workflow, WorkflowGen, Inceptico DMS, Intelex Business Management, Simple ECM, etc.

Reporting Tool / Dashboard:

Management level, department level, team level or individual level report generation is another important requirement for an ERP system. It is usually available in either a dashboard form (with a real-time data view – showing such info as orders received but not yet shipped, failed payments of the last week, etc.) or customizable reports generated in common word- or data-editing applications like spreadsheets.

Most reporting tools and dashboards operate in real-time (or with a minimal time lag). Like the applications used by departments for data updates, these reporting tools/ dashboard views are available as browser based or desktop installations. They also include end-of-day reporting features offering emailing of reports with charts/graphs/tables as Microsoft Excel or Word attachments.

Communication Tools:

Within any system working across multiple departments, communication is mandatory. ERP systems facilitate this by offering tools for action based automated mail generation, instant messaging, chat or general broadcast features at individual and group levels. Say once an order is marked as “Ready to Ship”, an automated mailer should be triggered to logistics department to initiate the dispatch process; Or if a pizza shop kitchen has developed a problem, a general broadcast message can be sent to all other departments to stop taking further orders.

Further instant messaging functions (like those from Lync, Chatter or Yammer) are incorporated to enable easy and instant communication.In addition to the above tools that are an integral part of any ERP system, there are additional ones which can be integrated on an as needed basis.

Analytical Tools:

A lot of analytical tools can be integrated within ERP system for business intelligence, predictive analysis, data mining and related analysis. These analytical tools are used to get valuable insights for creating strategic business decisions based on available data (like tracking consumer behavior around holiday shopping, comparative results for products in red colored shelf having more sales than those in blue colored shelf, etc.).

Resource Allocation & Task Scheduling Tools:

ERP systems can also integrate tools for allocating resources across departments and tasks (for labor intensive industries). These tools work on the simple principle of defined time taken by a task/project against the resource availability schedule. On task completion, the resource is automatically assigned a new task matching his skills, or is put in a pool for the next assignment. Tools have functionality for manual intervention at the supervisor level in case a task is delayed. Benefits include clear visibility about current and future workload, optimum resource utilization, exploring possibilities for automation, etc.

Other add on features

ERP systems can integrate modules for Human Resource Management, Project Management, Time Tracking systems, Document Management, etc., as per the business needs. There are a large number of tools available specific to each industry and function type, and ERP vendors provide their assistance to interested clients on selecting the best fit. Internet is always available for self-help on getting required info.

ERP is a complex framework to implement and usually needs a dedicated vendor for implementation. Two big bottlenecks identified with ERP implementations are high costs and the failure to adhere to best practices. While cost can be mitigated to a certain extent by careful valuation of different vendors and assessment of free open-source tools, the other challenge of failures due to lack of adherence to best practices can be mitigated by focused training to employees. Proper assessment at initial stages, partnering with vendors with right expertise and being clear on requirements from the start will help an efficient and successful implementation of ERP tools.

Popular ERP Tools in the market

ERP Tools:

There are several ERP software manufacturers and among them, prominent are SAP, Oracle Corporation, People Soft, JD Edwards, Lawson etc. SAP has the major share in the ERP market and next comes the Oracle Corporation. Oracle has bought JD Edwards, People Soft, and Siebel recently and they compete with SAP aggressively. Leading ERP software like SAP, Oracle Apps, etc., are focusing on all functionalists of an enterprise and few companies are focusing on certain domains only. Below are the popular ERP Tools and their respective vendor list.










ERP Tools & Vendors List:

ERP ToolsVendor List
SAP R/3SAP
Oracle e-Business SuiteOracle Corporation
JD Edwards EnterpriseOne & JD Edwards WorldOracle Corporation
PeopleSoftOracle Corporation
Microsoft DynamicsMicrosoft Corporation
Lawson FinancialsLawson Software
Sage MAS 500Sage Group
NetERPNetSuite
Visual EnterpriseInfor Global Solutions
Agresso Business WorldUnit 4 Agresso
Epicor EnterpriseEpicor
IFS ApplicationsIndustrial and Financial Systems
MFG/PROQAD
Ramco e.ApplicationsRamco Systems